Skip to content

🚀 Join the team! We’re looking for a new Digital Marketing Manager. View the Role.

Common Reasons Magento Projects Fail

(And How to Recover Them)

Common Reasons Magento Projects Fail

Not every failure of a Magento project is of a dramatic nature. It could be a store that opens late by 6 months. It could be a store that’s running just barely and is quietly losing the owners money. It could be a total meltdown which means conflicting extensions, an unmanageable theme, and agencies that have ghosted their clients.

No matter where you Magento failure has hit you, there are common patterns that can help you recover ans steer you in the right direction.

This was the case for many clients before you and below are the common cases and descriptions of what can be done to resolve the issue.

What "Magento Project Failure" Actually Looks Like

You’ve mentioned some loss scenarios, but before that, let’s clarify what is meant by failure here regarding your Magento project that should not be defined as a failure simply because the site went down. It has lost because of:

  • The store cannot be further developed due to the risk involved
  • It has become so bad that it is impacting conversion
  • The business has surpassed the limits of what the current setup can support
  • The original agency is unreachable, unreliable or just not right for the job
  • Security vulnerabilities are going unaddressed

If any of these fit your situation, then you are handling a project that is beyond recovery, not necessarily rebuilding.

Chris Junior Web Developer
The Most Common Reasons Magento Projects Fail
1. The Wrong Agency for the Job

Magento is a niche platform with a large knowledge gap between agencies that “do Magento” and those that actually specialize in it.

We often take over stores built by generalist agencies that have no clue how Magento’s architecture works. These sites all end up looking the same: one that works on the day of the launch and then becomes progressively harder to work with. This results in custom code being written outside of Magento’s module structure, poorly thought out compatibility when installing extensions, and other problems caused by short-term thinking that create obstacles come upgrade time.

This is about fit, not blame. If there isn’t a high level of technical expertise in the agency delivering the project, it is at risk from day one.

An extensive Magento audit will reveal what has been done, what the risk profile is, and a specialist agency can then evaluate what can be salvaged and what needs to be fully rebuilt.

2. Scope Creep Without Proper Change Control

Magento projects can be large and complex and can be prone to scope creep. This is particularly true without effective change control processes to manage scope and prevent the creation of technical debt that will be ignored.

Requirements are added during an integration build. Draft scopes for integrations are done over email. Custom requirements are added to firm fixed-price contracts without an adjustment. The development team is forced to work to a Date Driven Milestone, and the trade-offs made during the closing weeks of a project are the issues that will be present in the store for many years to come.

Create a definitive assessment of the current codebase and current scope. Assess whether an issue is “this should have been done properly” or “the business has moved on” and prioritize accordingly. More often than not, a piecemeal approach to rebuilding a system is preferable to a ‘big bang’ approach.

3. Poor Extension Management

The Magento Marketplace provides you with thousands of extensions. While this is a clear benefit to your business, it is also one of the top causes of instability we see.

Extensions can come from completely different vendors. When this is the case, the extensions do not work well together, and the more you install, the more conflicts you will face that are extremely difficult to troubleshoot. Adding extensions that have not been updated to the version of Magento that you are running can create a codebase that has security risks and compatibility problems.

Another issue is the heavy dependence on extensions for functionality that should have been developed custom. This reliance on extensions creates more friction during upgrades since each extension has to be reevaluated and retested.

An extension audit is part of a wider Magento audit. We look at every extension to determine compatibility, collect and analyze update histories to identify possible risks. Some extensions are replaced or removed entirely, while others are re-developed as proper custom modules.

4. Customisations That Bypass Core – and Can't Be Supported

This issue is specialized, but quite common. Developers that customize the core files in Magento rather than working within the framework of its modules have their changes undone every time Magento is updated. So, either the company never updates Magento (security risk), or the updates break things (operational risk).

We have taken over stores where critical business logic – pricing rules, checkout flows, integration code – was embedded directly in the core files. Untangling that is painstaking work, but it’s entirely possible to recover.

Core overrides should be removed from the core files and rebuilt as modules with appropriate scope. This is not quick, but it is the type of work that will provide long-term maintainability to a store. You should not have to compromise between security updates and having a store that works.

5. Neglected Magento Updates

Customers’ Magento websites are constantly at risk because security vulnerabilities are detected and published with each new iteration of Magento. Because Magento is an open-source platform, it will always allow the public to see and exploit weaknesses within each version. Therefore, if a merchant’s Magento storefront is not current with the most recent patches, then the vulnerabilities of the previous versions will be accessible.

As updates neglect, more and more changes occur in the system and the work required to bring the system up to date becomes that much greater. The tasks that need to accomplished in order to get the store current will always outweigh the concerns that caused the updates to be neglected.

Storing credit card data and other Personally Identifiable Information (PII) in data that is stored on Magento is illegal and a company can be sued if there is a security breach. If a Magento store is not updated, the risks only increase. An outdated Magento system becomes a liability.

We can help with upgrading your Magento system if the updates have been neglected. After completing an analysis of the target version to which you need to upgrade, we will evaluate any extension conflicts and devise a plan for the upgrade in stages, if is warranted. After the upgrades are complete, a current store requires a maintenance commitment to stay this way, which should be integrated into a retainer.

6. No Ongoing Support Structure

This could be considered the easiest failure to avoid. An unlaunched Magento store without a support agreement is going to deteriorate. Hosts will not be monitored, security patches will not be applied, and if the site breaks, no one will realize it for days.

This is even more problematic when the first agency is no longer involved. If no one has documented the server configuration, deployment steps, or code, it’s unnecessarily difficult to take over.

Most importantly, establish monitoring and various access credentials to document systems that are up and running. After that, you can identify the support gap and a plan to address it. A website management retainer will usually cover ongoing maintenance, monitoring, and minor development so that a Magento store does not continue to drift into trouble.

7. The Agency Relationship Broke Down

Sometimes the project was fine. The relationship was not.

An agency can leave a store stranded if it becomes unresponsive, or if it simply outgrows its interest in Magento support work. The business knows something needs addressing; the agency isn’t doing it. But the fear of what’s involved in changing agencies is enough to keep the business stuck.

With the right approach, switching Magento agencies is possible. The most important part is how you manage the handover and getting full access to all environments, code, keys, and documentation before the relationship ends.

We have created a guide on how to switch Magento agencies and this is covered in detail. The short answer is: get what you are entitled to, document what you get, and do not rush the handover.

Is it possible to recover a Magento project that has failed?

Are the stores going to be brought back to life? Almost always. But unfortunately it isn’t always fast or cheap.
A stores that seems to be in worse condition has problems for multiple issues listed above that have built up over time. Think core overrides, old extensions, no support structure, and an agency that is non-responsive. Untangling those issues takes structured and methodical work.

There has yet to be a Magento store that could not be stabilized and brought back to a workable state. The question is whether it makes more sense to try and recover the old store or use the situation as an opportunity to migrate to a properly built Magento 2 setup – especially if the store is still on Magento 1.

A Magento audit is typically the right starting point. It provides an objective perspective on the state of things and gives you an informed basis for the decision.

How Verve Approaches Magento Recovery

When we assume control of a struggling Magento store, we follow the same steps:

1. Access and documentation

We derive complete visibility of environment first and foremost. You might be surprised how frequently this step, in isolation, reveals previously unknown things.

2. Audit

Performance, security, code quality, extension compatibility, server setup. We fix things, sure, but we also document our findings.

3. Prioritisation

Not everything requires an immediate solution. We identify immediate risks vs medium-term improvements vs longer-term possibilities.

4. Structured recovery

We plan and communicate work, as opposed to being responsive. We do not function in a fire-fighting way.

5. Ongoing stability

Recovery is accompanied by a support structure to ensure the same issues do not happen again.
The Next Step

The best first step is to have a conversation. We look at what is going on with your store and provide a perspective about your choices. We don’t do hard sells.

You can read more about our Magento Rescue service, or what a Magento Audit involves. This is often the clearest way to see what you are working with.

Reach out to Mark and the team for a simple conversation about your Magento store. No strings attached.

Magento Audit
Fr £1.3k
Our Magento audit service provides a detailed health check of your online store, reviewing performance, security, configuration, extensions, custom code, checkout, integrations, and overall site stability. We identify hidden issues, highlight risks, and provide a clear, prioritised action plan to improve speed, reliability, security, and customer experience.
  • Identify Hidden Website Issues
  • Improve Site Speed and Performance
  • Reduce Risk Before Upgrades or Major Changes
  • Review Security and Best Practice Compliance
  • Assess Third-Party Extensions and Custom Code
  • Improve Conversion and Customer Experience
  • Highlight Operational and Admin Improvements
  • Clear, Prioritised Action Plan
Magento Audit Icon
Other Magento Services

Explore other Magento 2 options. Includes add services for improvement, safety, and sustained growth.

Magento 2 Website Project
Fr £20K
The Gold standard for ecommerce for many year, Magento 2 by Adobe offers extreme flexability to customise functionality to your businesses exact requirements, providing a soilid foundation to build on into the future.
  • Bespoke Design
  • Hyvä
  • Custom functionality development
  • Payment and accounting integration
  • Product data population
  • Bespoke ERP integration
  • Upgrades
  • Security retainer
Website Development Retainer
Fr £800/m
Local In-House Developers And 25+ Years Of Experience Delivering Stunning Websites That Fuel Business Growth.
  • Production, Staging & Local Development Environments
  • Peer to peer code reviews
  • Automated testing
  • Website Heartbeat
  • Platform updates
Magento Updates
Fr £80 /m
Monthly updates and checks for your website to keep your site secure from known vulnerabilities.
  • PHP updates
  • Plugin updates
  • Core platform updates
  • Module updates

Frequently Asked Questions

You want to get access to all environments and get the site stabilized. That may be a short term patch for now. Once the immediate problem is stabilized, you can do a full audit and determine the rest.
It really depends on what exactly all is broken. Depending on the extent of the damage, stabilizing the store may take a few days. If you are dealing with a lot of technical debt, recovery will take weeks to months, depending on how the work is prioritized.
Yes, it can be challenging to finalize the handover correctly, but it is quite common for us when new clients come on. Just make sure you have full ownership and access to everything before the handover.
The answer to that is a Magento audit. Recovery is the less expensive option in almost all cases, however if the structure is completely incorrect, rebuilding it will be the better long-term solution.
It depends on the state of the store. It is best to perform an audit to get an understanding of the current state before defining the scope of the rescue project.

Related reading