Case Study: How Targeted PPC Grew Enquiries for a Construction Supplier
The client – a regional provider of construction materials for use by contractors and merchant builders – asked for “visibility” on Google. We rejected that out of hand. Visibility without a clear positioning strategy is money wasted, and for a regional supplier in construction who can only compete on price against national distributors, he will lose every time.
So before we ever touched an account, we established the positioning for him: What competitors’ options does he really beat? (Next-day regional delivery and technical assistance which most national distributors don’t provide.) Who cares about that? (Contractors and builders whose programs demand it, not procurement people looking for the cheapest unit cost.) Which enquiries do we want to generate? Not impressions, but enquiries from the right trade buyer based on his capacity to deliver.
The starting position
At the time we took on the account, the client had a sole broad match campaign for phrases such as “building supplies” and “construction materials.” Monthly budget was £4,200. There was enough activity – the dashboards were filled with data – but enquiries received turned out to be out-of-town, single-item buyers who were never returning.
In terms of Lean methodology, the account was doing the wrong things brilliantly well. Lots of activity, almost no validated learning, and vanity metrics going up all the while the sales team simply ignored the leads.
The truth behind the statistics
CTR was good. Impression share was growing. But when enquiries were matched against the pipeline, it turned out that less than 9% of them resulted in quotation and even less turned into an order. The account was optimizing itself in the metric which was destined to go up anyway while the business needed another result.
Our first task wasn’t to increase the budget. It was to change the criteria of success from impressions to enquiries we really wanted the sales team to get.
Every campaign was a hypothesis, not a bet
We didn’t rebuild the account in one go. We ran it as a series of tests — each with a plain-language hypothesis and a metric designed to prove us wrong if we were.
Hypothesis: constraining geographic targeting to the supplier’s actual next day delivery range will reduce wastage spend while still maintaining a level of qualified inquiries. Result: proven true. Inquiry volumes decreased marginally, however cost-per-qualified inquiry reduced by 22% in six weeks and the sales team stopped turning away out of area inquiries.
Hypothesis: people searching for particular products and technical specifications perform better than people searching category terms. Result: proven true. Product-specific and specification keywords (for example, grade, size and compliance) converted almost three times higher than category keywords and so we adjusted spend based on that.
Hypothesis: trade buyers from programs which extend for longer periods of time seldom ask questions on the initial visit, therefore there will be demand recapture using a nurture layer. Result: proven true and the most surprising one. Trade buyers returning through the nurture layer became our most valuable quote generation segment.
How we built demand instead of chasing attention
-
We designed for oversubscription, not maximum spendThe supplier was constrained by its ability to deliver, so swamping the account with inquiries it could not answer would be harmful to its reputation rather than beneficial. We were aware of the demand and the available capacity and we spent our budget in such a way that the number of inquiries remained slightly ahead of the ability to handle them effectively.
-
We respected the long sales cycleConstruction buyers usually carry out their research many months prior to the start of work at the construction site. As opposed to perceiving a slower-to-close lead as a “cold” one, we considered it to be upstream of the stage when it needed us and supplied it with nurturing information.
-
We only ran claims we'd be happy for buyers to reverse-engineerNo faking scarcity or urgency. If the ads talked about next-day shipping or inventory, it was the real deal. Only when the capacity actually was scarce did we use scarcity messaging – and in our case, as a local vendor, it really was.
-
We reviewed every test honestly, wins and losses alikeOne of our broad match display tests, that we felt quite sure would perform well, performed poorly and we turned it off after three weeks. The lessons from this failed test were as valuable as the success stories, if not more so.
The results, without the spin
This wasn’t a straight line. Two of our early tests underperformed and were cut. Total spend rose modestly over the period — this was efficiency and better targeting doing the heavy lifting, not a bigger budget. And the nurture layer took months to pay off, which is exactly why it’s the stage most accounts skip and the one we over-invested in.
Results in one construction account don’t guarantee identical numbers in another. The method — position, hypothesis, honest review — is what transfers.
What we’d caveat
This wasn’t a straight line. Two of our early tests underperformed and were cut. Total spend rose modestly over the period — this was efficiency and better targeting doing the heavy lifting, not a bigger budget. And the nurture layer took months to pay off, which is exactly why it’s the stage most accounts skip and the one we over-invested in.
Results in one construction account don’t guarantee identical numbers in another. The method – position, hypothesis, honest review – is what transfers.